Concerning Navigraph development, I think it’s time to integrate new ideas: 1. concerning XP12, Co-Pilot/in and AI ATC. My idea is to get license from JAR design after his resignation as basic and start point for further development his C-Pilot concept including his X-Life plugin for airport traffic and a simple ATC. He had a great idea but not the needed technical knowledge how to develop his plugins to a sort AI add-ons. In my opinion it has a potential but need a fresh dynamic and innovative team for realization. I think it is well connected to Navigraph concept for the near future